Bought this guide book 2 weeks ago in HongKong…..it was published in Nov 2008 and received lots of harsh critics from local connoisseurs of food specaily with the low rating of the famous Chinese food restaurants in HongKong/Macau. However because of these critics I went to get the book..a free marketing I guess.
According to the rating guide from the book their star rating(1-3 while 3 is the best) is based on quality, combination, technical skill and flair with their preparation,clarity and combination of flavours value for money and the consistency (since they had revisited the restaurants to test them).. The location, ambience, equipments, even service are not being considered
And there are only one Star rating to most of the local well known Chinese favourties like Yung Kee, Forum , Fook Lam Mom( famous for those Shark’s Fins Soup, Abalone dishes)…etc, only one new Chinese Restaurant at the Four Season Hotel got a 3 Stars rating, therefore those connoisseurs saying that the westerners(actually we dont’ know the inspectors are either westerners or chinese or whatever) don’t really appreciated the art of chinese food, therefore they will treat the guide book as a joke.
Well after I have read through the book I am surprised quite a number of worldwide Chef’s owned like the Nobu, Spoon by Alain Ducasse at InterContinental Hotel, or Ruth’s Chris Steak House well as some other famous Hotel Restaurants offering western food like Grissini of Grand Hyatt, Gaddi’s from Pennisula , have not received even one Star, on the other hand some small places like the Noodle/Congee shop Ho Hung Kee, at least received a recommandation.
Everyone of us have our own preference on choosing food and or restaurnats - my favourite may be your worst. I still think this book is quite informative and useful for finding my next meal in HongKong though I will also take the service, ambience into consideration.



























































































